SC2261
Joachim Ansorg edited this page Nov 12, 2021
·
2 revisions
Multiple redirections compete for stdout. Use cat, tee, or pass filenames instead.
(or stdin, or stderr, or FD 3)
Problematic code:
grep foo < input1 < input2 > output1 > output2 > output3Correct code:
# Merge inputs into a single stream, write outputs individually
cat input1 input2 | grep foo | tee output1 output2 > output3
# Pass inputs as filenames, write outputs individually
grep foo input1 input2 | tee output1 output2 > output3Rationale:
A file descriptor, whether stdin, stdout, stderr, or non-standard ones, can only point to a single file/pipe.
For input, many commands support processing multiple filenames. In these cases you can just specify the filenames instead of redirecting. Alternatively, you can use cat to merge multiple filenames into a single stream.
For output, you can use tee to write to multiple output sinks in parallel.
Exceptions:
Zsh will automatically cat inputs and tee outputs, but none of the shells supported by ShellCheck do.
Related resources:
- Help by adding links to BashFAQ, StackOverflow, man pages, POSIX, etc!